The Philosophical Thesis Of Incompatibilism - 966 Words

The philosophical thesis of incompatibilism, at moments, seems very puzzling because it has two opposite ideas in it; hard determinism and libertarian free will. How can hard determinists and libertarians be comparable in a thesis called incompatibilism, when the two of them have two very opposite concepts? One denies free will, and the other one endorse it. It is comprehensible when both determinism and indeterminism are being compared, but not when we do it with compatibilism and incompatibilism; These last two concepts do not appear to be coherent with the concept of freedom. Hard determinists are those who says everything is determined, and it follows from that that we are not free, that we do not have morally significance freedom (Chaffee). For example: If a person chooses salt over sugar, that choice was not his or her choice because it was pre-determined, and was caused by something. The problem of free will comes down to the notion of moral responsibility. On the contrary, someone that thinks that free will is incompatible with determinism, that we do have free will and that therefore determinism is false, is called a Libertarian. Nothing forces a libertarian to do what he/she wants to do freely. For example, imagine a person is at the supermarket and has in front of him the potato section and the sweet potato section. He chooses to grab a potato instead of a sweet potato. At that very moment, when he is grabbing the potato, he has chosen to grab the potato.Show MoreRelated The Free Will Debate Essay2989 Words   |  12 PagesThe unique ability that each and every individual possesses that enable him/her to control their actions is known as free will. Free will is directly connected to two other vital philosophical issues: freedom of action and moral accountability, which is the main reason why the debate is so vital. Simply stated, a person who has free will refers to an individual’s ability to choose his or her route of action. However, animals also appear to suit this measure, further adding to the debate because freeRead MoreThe Nature Of Free Will Essay2312 Words   |  10 Pagesor social or psychological phenomena are causally determined by preceding events or natural laws.† Whether or not determinism is true is an empirical matter that can only be solved by scientific inquiry into how the world works and not through philosophical arguments. However, the implications of the truth of determinism would’ve have a significant effect on free will. There are two ways in which the world could turn out not t o be deterministic. One would be if there are things in the universe thatRead MoreHuman Freedom And The Self1822 Words   |  8 PagesOne of the big dilemmas in the philosophical community surrounds whether humans have free will in determining their choices or whether forces outside human control determine actions. A solution to the problem has long been sought since it involves one of the core beliefs about human nature. Furthermore, whether or not humans have free will has influence on whether humans can be subject to praise or blame. Within this problem, there are three main schools of thought: compatibilism, hard determinism